Mar 23, 2020 arendt raises the question of whether thinking itself was opposed to evildoing, regardless of the content of thought, and linked the activity of thinking with conscience. Hannah arendt on conscience and the banality of evil. Richard wolin on arendts banality of evil thesis by seyla benhabib seyla benhabib rejoins the debate, contesting wolins critique of arendts. Once upon a time there lived a lady named hannah arendt, who wrote a book called eichmann in jerusalem. More than 50 years after its publication, hannah arendts eichmann in. The banality of evil thesis is the notion that ordinary people commit barbaric acts without realisation of what they are doing. This is a revised and enlarged edition of the book which first appeared in may, 1963. An alternative history of philosophy by arranging interconnected narrative videos to. Arendts grandparents were members of the reform jewish community there. A revised and enlarged edition was published in 1964. If something is banal, it is common, boring and unoriginal. To arendts mind, eichmann willingly did his part to organize the holocaust and an instrumental part it was. Arendt helps us to understand the weight of collective responsibility.
I covered the eichmann trial at jerusalem in 1961 for the new yorker, where this account, slightly abbreviated, was originally published in february and march, 1963. Hannah arendt banality of evil theory eichmann on screen. The origins of totalitarianism harvest book, hb244. Hannah arendts challenge to adolf eichmann judith butler in her treatise on the banality of evil, arendt demanded a rethink of established ideas about moral responsibility. Sep 03, 2014 book portrays eichmann as evil, but not banal. A report on the banality of evil, she fo imageoriginal in its thesis, modern in its i definition of criminality. The book was focused on adolf eichmann, who was one of the major architects of the holocaust.
The idea, emblazoned in the subtitle of her controversial 1963 book, eichmann in jerusalem, impressed many people as a fundamental insight into a new and distinctly modern. The trial of hannah arendt national endowment for the. It is indeed my opinion now that evil is never radical, that it is only extreme. Hannah arendt and the final solution kindle edition by bergen, bernard j download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. What hannah arendt meant by the banality of evil remains a puzzle. This complete absence of thinking is what attracted the philosophers interest and that is how she started to question the problem of the eventual inner connection between the ability or inability to think and the problem of evil. A report on the banality of evil, she formulated a disturbing imageoriginal in its thesis, modern in its implications, bold in its definition of criminality.
A report on the banality of evil, her controversial analysis of the jerusalem trial of adolf eichmann, had just been published in german in the federal republic and gaus used the occasion to generate a portrait of hannah arendt. Hannah arendts challenge to adolf eichmann judith butler. The banality of evil from a jungian view stottilien. Book portrays eichmann as evil, but not banal the new york.
The capacity for evil can spread like an epidemic elisabeth. As i read, the controversial nature of arendt s book was brought home to me. Arendt, a jew who fled germany during adolf hitlers rise to power, reported on adolf eichmanns trial for the new yorker. Arendt explained that she had not attempted in the book to articulate a comprehensive theory of the essence of evil, but rather intended to point to a phenomenon she had noticed during the trial. It is obvious from reading the book that has account of the trial in the. The grossly misunderstood banality of evil theory israel. A report on the banality of evil, her book on the trial of nazi lieutenantcolonel adolf eichmann.
This highly original book is the first to explore the political and philosophical consequences of hannah arendts concept of the banality of evil, a term she used to. Oct 14, 2014 richard wolin responds to benhabibs ringing reaffirmation of hannah arendts notion of the banality of evil. Elie kedourie begins his article mean spirits nyr, november 22 with an attack on hannah arendt. Nov 07, 2019 not that banal is the same as the everyday. Arendt, hannah internet encyclopedia of philosophy. To presentday readers, arendt is associated first of all with the notion the banality of evil, coined in her book eichmann in jerusalem 1965a. This highly original book is the first to explore the political and philosophical consequences of hannah arendts concept of the banality of evil, a term she used to describe adolph eichmann.
What seems to lie behind this idea is that eichmann was no more than a. Instead, he presents an alternative framework that can explain why some states become totalitarian and why they induce people to commit evil acts. Eichmanns evil was, she claimed, banal in the sense that it was the evil of a bureaucrat, of an office manager, rather than a devil. From the moment the articles that eventually comprised her book eichmann in jerusalem. Hannah arendt on how to see evil and survive it in 1961, the new yorker commissioned arendt to report on the trial of adolf eichmann in jerusalem hannah arendt october 14, 1906december 4, 1975 understood that evil does not announce itself with fanfare and a jet of sulphur. The author pushes the concept of totalitarianism back into the premodern period and challenges hannah arendts notion of the banality of evil. Though arendts book was subtitled a report on the banality of evil, the term itself appears only once in the text, near the end. What are the origins of the phrase, the banality of evil. It defies thought for as soon as thought tries to engage itself with evil and examine the premises and principles from which it originates, it is frustrated because it finds nothing there. Relevance of hannah arendts a report on the banality of evil to gaza. Arendt was prompted to clarify her intentions in a postscript to the book.
T here have been few phrases that have proved as controversial as the famous subtitle hannah arendt chose to sum up her account of the 1961 trial of adolf eichmann. The book is a very, very short synopsis and i was expecting a lot more into the nitty gritty of the. Eichmann in jerusalem by hannah arendt reading guide. Hannah arendt coined the term banality of evil while covering the 1961 trial of adolf eichmann, a nazi official charged with the orderly extermination of europes jews. Hannah arendt october 14, 1906december 4, 1975 understood that evil does not announce itself with fanfare and a jet of sulphur. Re book portrays genocidal nazi as evil, but not banal arts pages, sept. Hannah arendt is a twentieth century political philosopher whose writings do not easily come together into a systematic philosophy that expounds and expands upon a single argument over a sequence of works. Nov 29, 2017 the new york times recently did a profile on neonazis in america and their readers are very unhappy about it. Hannah arendts notion of the banality of evil has been consistently misunderstood as. Instead, her thoughts span totalitarianism, revolution, the nature of freedom and the.
That year, intelligence operatives from the young nation of israel kidnapped. Among those who misunderstood her notion of the banality of evil to mean a trivialization of the outcome of evil rather than an insight into the commonplace motives of its perpetrators was the scholar gerhard scholem, with whom arendt had corresponded warmly for decades. Arendt, a jew who fled germany during adolf hitlers rise to power, reported on adolf eichmann s trial for the new yorker. Evil can never truly be beautiful, for beauty is a property of being. This book offers a contribution to rectifying this imbalance by providing a critical engagement with arendtian ethics. This highly original book is the first to explore the political and philosophical consequences of hannah arendts concept of the banality of evil, a term she used to describe adolph eichmann, architect of the nazi final solution. The first edition of the novel was published in may 17th 1963, and was written by hannah arendt. Richard wolin on arendts banality of evil thesis jewish. The interview ranged across a wide field of topics, including the difference. A report on the banality of evil study guide contains a biography of hannah arendt, quiz questions, major themes, characters, and a full summary and analysis. Anyone who reads hannah arendts writings which offer numerous insights about the banality of evil, even when she doesnt use the term directly cannot take seriously the propositions ascribed to her by sociologist eva illouz.
Richard wolin on arendts banality of evil thesis by seyla benhabib seyla benhabib rejoins the debate, contesting wolins critique of arendts banality thesis on historical and philosophical grounds. The art of social distancing according to hannah arendt. Download pdf the banality of evil free online new books. In arendts 1963 words, the lesson of the trial was that of the fearsome, wordandthoughtdefying banality of evil. From the first the notion of the banality of evil proved highly contentious and it is still a stumbling block for some of the most astute and sympathetic expositors of. Arendt did not elaborate on what she meant by the phrase but readers can understand what she meant due to hints throughout the book. Hannah arendt and the banality of evil open source with. Arendt chose to prefer the term extreme evil over the kantian radical evil, in order to emphasize that extreme evil is always found in a sequence of different types of evil, at varying levels. Arendt herself was a germanjewish exile struggling in the most personal of ways to come to grips with the utter destruction of european society. Hannah arendt coined the term banality of evil while covering the 1961. Apr 23, 2018 arendt dubbed these collective characteristics of eichmann the banality of evil. If hannah arendt 190675 leaves no other intellectual legacy, her notion of the banality of evil seems certain to ensure her a place in the history of western thought. Hannah arendt on the banality of evil 1769 words bartleby. Thought tries to reach some depth, to go to the roots, and the moment it concerns itself with evil, it is frustrated.
Even before its publication as a book, hannah arendts eichmann in jerusalem. This, for her, was the truly frightening thing, because it meant that eichmann could not be dismissed as mad or as different from the rest of us. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read eichmann in jerusalem. The crime against humanity by jerome kohn, director, hannah arendt center, new school university. A report on the banality of evil were published in the new yorker, the idea that the execution of the nazis diabolical plans for an. Gershom scholem, a fellow philosopher and theologian, wrote to arendt in 1963 that her banalityofevil thesis was merely a slogan that does not impress me, certainly, as the product of profound analysis. Eichmann accepted and espoused the idea of racial purity.
Conscience does not figure among the topics for which arendts work is most known. A report on the banality of evil and was prompted at last to do so when i found the book on sale at my local library. Covering the trial arendt coined the phrase the banality of evil, a phrase that has. In her treatise on the banality of evil, arendt demanded a rethink of established ideas about moral responsibility. Aug 19, 2011 a book would be required to report how the banality of evil has become banal over the decades since hannah arendt published her controversial eichmann in jerusalem 1963. One reason for the initial bewilderment was that arendt did not explain the term in the books first edition. One searches in vain for an essay or book of hers devoted to it. Mary mccarthy with hannah arendt, aberdeen, scotland, ca. Arendt herself was a germanjewish exile struggling in the most personal of ways to come to grips with the utter destruction of. Hannah arendt was born johanna cohn arendt in 1906 into a comfortable educated secular family of german jews in linden, prussia now a part of hanover, in wilhelmine germany. In 1960, the israelis captured adolph eichmann, a fugitive nazi war criminal living in argentina. A book would be required to report how the banality of evil has become banal over the decades since hannah arendt published her controversial eichmann in.
The book was published in multiple languages including english, consists of 312 pages and is available in paperback format. Many of you may have heard of the term the banality of evil in passing, or perhaps mentioned in a book somewhere. Quite possibly, some of you may never have heard of it. Jul 31, 20 fifty years after hannah arendt came out with her controversial book, eichmann in jerusalem. To arendts mind, eichmann willingly did his part to organize the holocaust and an instrumental part it was out of neither anti. Why do hannah arendts ideas about evil and the holocaust. Arendt asserts that the crimes of the holocaust revealed a shift in ethics and the need for new responses to a new kind of evil. Arendt, a jew who fled germany during adolf hitlers. If arendt thought existing notions of legal intention and national criminal courts were. In a wellknown work on the eichmann trial hannah arendt perversely floated the notion of the banality of evil.
The book immediately set off a controversy that a halfcentury later shows no signs of. Hannah arendts mother, who considered herself progressive, sought to raise her daughter along strict goethean lines, which amongst other things, involved the reading of the complete works of goethe, often summed up in the phrase from wilhelm meisters apprenticeship 1796 as was aber ist deine pflicht. Bergen, the questions that preoccupied arendt were the meaning and significance of the nazi genocide to our modern times. Why does hannah arendts banality of evil still anger. Nor, as stated by hannah arendt herself in the postscript, is this book intended to. Arendt dubbed these collective characteristics of eichmann the banality of evil. Free download or read online eichmann in jerusalem. A report on the banality of evil is a 1963 book by political theorist hannah arendt. Arendt used the words the banality of evil to describe what she saw in eichmann. Jul 07, 2009 this short video is from an extensive interview with susan neiman that adapted her book evil in modern thought. Relevance of hannah arendts a report on the banality of. In 1961, the new yorker commissioned arendt to report on the trail of adolf eichmann in jerusalem. That there is nothing in evil for thought to latch onto is what arendt meant by the banality of evil.
Hannah arendt, an american professor and scholar of political theory, herself a german jewish refugee, wanted. Hannah arendt most memorably employed it in both the subtitle and closing words of eichmann in jerusalem. By banality of evil, arendt had in mind two interconnected ideas. Opinion the banality of evil, and the nazis early victims. A report on the banality of evil ebook written by hannah arendt. This was the revolutionary and, like every revolutionary idea, at the time controversial point that hannah arendt october 14, 1906december 4. In arendts telling, eichmann reminds us of the protagonist in albert camuss novel the. Book portrays eichmann as evil, but not banal the new.
The vast majority of studies of hannah arendts thought are concerned with her as a political theorist. He came across as a bland, passionless, simple man. Fifty years after hannah arendt came out with her controversial book, eichmann in jerusalem. Hannah arendt s study of the eichmann trial i had long wanted to read hannah arendt s 1906 1975 study of the eichmann trial, eichmann in jerusalem. The new york times recently did a profile on neonazis in america and their readers are very unhappy about it. What did hannah arendt really mean by the banality of evil. Specifically, she reexamined her notion of the banality of evil, noting that with eichmann, extreme evil didnt seem to come from pride, envy, hatred, covetousness or moral monstrosity, but rather from sheer thoughtlessness. Arendt argued that the characteristic of modern evilits very banalitywas the proper lens through which to view eichmanns actions and the rebuttal to his own defense. Hannah arendt and the final solution by bergen, bernard j. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Hence illouzs baseless notion that the banality of evil does not distinguish between types of evil. The great moral lessonarticulated by both augustine and hannah arendtis that we must refuse to be beguiled by the glittering banality of wickedness and we must consistently choose the substance over the shadow. Hannah arendt elaborated on the notion of banality of evil through the case of eichmann. Hannah arendt on the normalization of human wickedness and our only effective antidote to it under conditions of terror most people will comply but some people will not no more is required, and no more can reasonably be asked, for this planet to remain a place fit for human habitation.
1284 1153 1324 271 1162 390 894 1472 224 528 1014 1125 948 1317 969 692 1064 1245 842 1442 403 1207 635 526 168 1270 495 654 54 219 508 506 28 807 134 50